College Men: Stop Getting Drunk
It’s closely associated with sexual assault. And yet we’re reluctant to tell men to stop doing it.
Slate’s Emily Yoffe lit up a firestorm in social media with an article earlier this morning with the headline and subtitle, “College Women: Stop Getting Drunk. It’s closely associated with sexual assault. And yet we’re reluctant to tell women to stop doing it.” As a writer, I know that article titles are not written by authors and can actually even undermine the point of a piece. But, that’s not what happened here. Yoffe carefully provides gender-neutral statistics regarding sexual assault and binge drinking on campus. Her conclusions?
“A common denominator in these cases is alcohol, often copious amounts, enough to render the young woman incapacitated.”
How about: “A common denominator in these cases is a lack of education, often a copious lack, about consent and what constitutes rape.”
“A misplaced fear of blaming the victim has made it somehow unacceptable to warn inexperienced young women that when they get wasted, they are putting themselves in potential peril.”
“A misplaced fear of women’s unconstrained sexuality and a reluctance to address sexual double standards has made it somehow unacceptable to warn young men and women about the realities of sexual assault and predatory rape.”
Yoffe wants girls to understand that getting drunk is risky for them and would like them not to get drunk. Funny how articles like this just don’t focus on boys not drinking to avoid higher risk of raping and facing terrible consequences.
Yoffe goes on to quote Christopher Krebs, the author of several studies of campus sexual assault: “I’m not saying a woman is responsible for being sexually victimized. But when your judgment is compromised, your risk is elevated of having sexual violence perpetrated against you.” Adds Yoffe, “Let’s be totally clear: Perpetrators are the ones responsible for committing their crimes, and they should be brought to justice. But we are failing to let women know that when they render themselves defenseless, terrible things can be done to them.”
Here’s what I say: “Let’s be totally clear: Perpetrators are the ones responsible for committing their crimes, and they should be brought to justice. But we are failing to let men know that when they get drunk or engage in sexual activity with someone who is drunk and incapable of consent, they are at higher risk for being rapists and face terrible consequences.”
“If I had a son, I would tell him that it’s in his self-interest not to be the drunken frat boy who finds himself accused of raping a drunken classmate,” concludes Joffe. Really? “Finds himself” like he’s wandering blindly through the woods?
Parents and educators have roughly 18 years in which to educate their children prior to college. They are failing. And they are failing because we live in a society in which pleasure, especially for women, is illicit and sex is still steeped in shame and silence. Binge drinking and confusion resulting in sexual assault, especially one in which victim blaming plays a significant role, share a common root: puritanism. The same culture that teaches that sex is shameful, dangerous and illicit is the one that significantly increases the likelihood of alcohol abuse. American children going into college explode in anti-repressive frenzies of “freedom” borne of a laughable but dangerous denial of healthy teenage development.
Colleges have, until recently being forced to confront the issue, had incredibly high tolerance for sexual assault. They routinely fail to hold rapists accountable, pass out ridiculous penalties, lie about rates of assault on campus and more. The exact same approach to ending binge drinking cited by Joffe, namely “coercion, enforcement, and social engineering,” are required to end institutional tolerance of sexual assault.
Yoffe concludes, so very oddly, that this is feminisms fault. “Young women are getting a distorted message that their right to match men drink for drink is a feminist issue. The real feminist message should be that when you lose the ability to be responsible for yourself, you drastically increase the chances that you will attract the kinds of people who, shall we say, don’t have your best interest at heart. That’s not blaming the victim; that’s trying to prevent more victims.”
The only “real feminist message” about this subject is that non-consensual sex is rape, that drunk people cannot consent to rape and that rapists, not their victims, should be held accountable.
The solution to keeping girls safe, which is Yoffe’s intent in this article, is to educate boys and girls as early as possible about consent, bodily integrity, respect, open communication and safety. Long before they are thrown into an alcohol-fog. Like in elementary school. It really isn’t funny how articles re college, sexual assault & alcohol rarely focus on boys not drinking to avoid higher risk of being jailed for risky behavior, like rape and sexual assault.
We should be dismantling double standards and victim-blaming rape mythologies, not contributing to them. Yoffe wants to keep her daughter safe, which is understandable, we all do. These are profoundly systemic problems, and this approach - taking up valuable time and space - is counter productive. There was a time when it was culturally acceptable for drunk people to express themselves in racist and homophobic ways. Over time, that has changed so that this is not acceptable and shame accrues to the racist or homophobe, not to the person assaulted. Some people have a hard time putting sexual assault in the same category and envisioning rape as rare instead of the commonplace crime that it is. If people are concerned about nuances and confusion then they should eliminate ambiguity by educating children. Not telling women not to get drunk is just click-bait, victim-shaming 101.
- there-was-a-girl reblogged this from sorayachemaly
- there-was-a-girl likes this
- fishcaken reblogged this from sorayachemaly
- kingofherrings likes this
- cuddlegrumps likes this
- hard-int likes this
- lizgrandmaison likes this
- c-rhea-dossier likes this
- lilbrawngurl reblogged this from sorayachemaly
- lilbrawngurl likes this
- katyvonk likes this
- photomunchies likes this
- darklydreamingdraca likes this
- 33313dcr likes this
- 33313dcr reblogged this from sorayachemaly
- staysensible likes this
- theheartbeatofatimelordx likes this
- jennifer-erin reblogged this from sorayachemaly
- eve-rebil reblogged this from sorayachemaly
- no-k-cupid likes this
- lesflammables likes this
- claudewriter reblogged this from sorayachemaly
- whatimagination likes this
- omeletsforpepper reblogged this from sorayachemaly
- sirtripsalot likes this
- lunatefossa likes this
- feministlibrarian likes this
- solestria reblogged this from sorayachemaly
- bestworstideaever reblogged this from sorayachemaly
- bestworstideaever likes this
- sophicgoddess likes this
- redfan4ever reblogged this from sorayachemaly
- pixielauren reblogged this from sorayachemaly and added:
- andieepandaa reblogged this from sorayachemaly
- femmefemmefeminist reblogged this from sorayachemaly
- stellajames reblogged this from sorayachemaly and added:
- iamobsolete likes this
- misplacedducksfan reblogged this from sorayachemaly
- delusionedxdreamer reblogged this from sorayachemaly
- dirtpuddle reblogged this from sorayachemaly
- serriform likes this
- coldmorningsun reblogged this from sorayachemaly
- healthy-skepticism likes this
- mavaddat likes this
- cultivatingcognizance reblogged this from sorayachemaly
- goddessstorm reblogged this from sorayachemaly
- goddessstorm likes this
- sufferingzen reblogged this from sorayachemaly
- seagullcountry reblogged this from sorayachemaly